Harrison, R. Helpful Resources. Soft cover. Hard cover. The Mythology of Modern Dating Methods. GB July 20th, I get the impression from the article that frink has been honest and honourable in his interactions with critics in assessing the weaknesses of his system. I don't know that the same could be said for rational wiki. I see they deny the soft tissue in dino finds, referencing a test that apparently concluded biofilm as the explanation.
I don't understand all the technical details, but you make it clear enough for me to get the general idea.
David S. US July 20th, In the quotes there is an telling confusion between data and method. Data is data and can be "spurious" if it was written down wrong, measured wrong, made up, etc. Usually data is not the problem.
Oxidizable carbon ratio dating
If a method gives incorrect or inconsistent results it's not the data that's spurious. AU July 20th, The bible makes no mention the C12 : C14 ratios were upset by the flood burial of organic matter nor any mention of any organic matter burial. How do you know about such burial and ratio upsets; were you there? Tas Walker July 21st, You are correct that we were not there, so the discussion about the effect of the Flood on carbon ratio is speculation. However this should come as no surprise to you because it takes exactly the same line that all geologists use when they speculate about cause and effect of events in the past.
One article where this approach is discussed is Flood models and biblical realism.
What we do know for sure is that there was a global Flood and that it occurred about 4, years ago. Thus we know that all carbon dates and OCR dates which are calibrated by c that are greater than about 4, years BP are incorrect. That is when we speculate as to the reasons why they are wrong and consider what sort of corrections need to be made to the underlying assumptions. Can I encourage you to read the account of the Flood in Genesis chapters 6 to 9.
Think about all the details described that point to the geological processes that were occurring at that time and consider what effect that would have had on the features of the earth. Don't attack individuals, denominations, or other organizations. Stay on-topic. We're not here to debate matters like eschatology, baptism, or Bible translation. Recently published research data challenges the presumed biological stability of carbonized organic matter, or charcoal Frink, These articles con- clude that charcoal undergoes changes through time that can be detected by stan- dard chemical soil analyses.
Soil samples containing charcoal were obtained from archaeological contexts of known age throughout the New England states. The results of these two chemical analysesdemonstratea decreasinglinear relationshipto time when ex- pressedas a ratio of total C to readily oxidizable C.
This ratio is called the OCR. The rate of biochemical degradationof the charcoal varies within the specific physical and environmentalcontextsof the sample. Thesevariablesaremeasuredby soil texture and depthbelow the soil sur- face, the site specific mean annual temperatureand rainfall, percentageof total C, and the soil pH.Primary, Secondary, Tertiary Hydrogen & Quarternary Carbon Atoms, Alcohols, Amines, & Alkyl Halides
Residual influences on this system are included through a statistically derived constant Frink, Paststudieshavecomparedthe resultsfor total organicmatterof the Walkley and Black and Ball Loss on Ignition procedureson soil samplesobtained from the organicallyenrichedA, E, andplow zonehorizons Amadon, ;Bonemisza et al.
The Walkley and Black procedure,however, mea- sures only the more readily oxidizable C compoundsin the soil and thus pro- vides an incompletemeasureof organic C. For surfaceorganically enrichedho- rizons A, E, and plow zone ,the total organic C recoveredby the Walkley and Black procedure varies from Data from 14Cradiocarbonanalysesand historic documentationon the age of samplesfrom archaeologicalsites throughout New England demonstratea strong direct correlation betweenthe ageof the C andthe amountof C recovered by the Walkley and Black procedure Frink, The environmental factors that directly affect the relative oxidizability of the carbonized organic matter arerainfall, temperature,soil reactivity pHtexture and depth of sample below surface 0, permeabilityand the total available C.
Rainfall and temperatureaffect soil development. Soil pH decreaseswith increasedrainfall. Lower soil pH directly affects the extent of leaching and rate of organic decomposition Jenny, Soil depth and texture affect the rate of 0, diffusion, and thus the growth and depth of root development Stolzy et al.
As depth increases,0, and root growth decreases. Coarse-texturedsoils have a higher rate of 0, diffusion, with a correspondingincreasein the rate and depth of root growth.
Carbonized or burned forms of C are relatively resistantto biochemical alteration, and are not believed to significantly contribute to the agronomic value of soils.
For this reason,the microbial agentscausingthe biochemical alteration of charcoalhave not beenextensivelyresearched. The factor of time affectsthe rate and the dura- tion of biochemical processes. Soil pH affects both chemical and biological processesin the soil Jenny, The relationship between variables in a systemmay be expressedby a number of mathematical equations;however, certain equationswill describethe samplepopulation better than others.
The best equation will describethe samplepopulation as a normal distribution curve with the highestKurtosis. The various possibleequationswere solved for a population of 58 samples,and the following equation and constant were statistically determinedto be the best description of this system. While the OCR procedureprovides good ageestimatesfor many archaeo- logical samples,it cannot be applied to all situations.
Specific environmental conditions must be met before meaningful ageestimatesarepossible. The change in the oxidizable C ratio through time andthe formulation of the OCR,, equa- tion, were derived from samplesobtainedfrom moderatelyto well drained aero- bic soils. Resultsfrom the analysesconductedon samplesobtained from poorly drained anaerobicsoils yielded spuriousdata,suggestingthat OCR,, equation pertains to an 0, dependentsystem. Soil samplesaffected by long-term satura- tion reducing conditions returnedageestimatesmuch older than expected.
This is probably due to interferenceby reducedCl, Fe, and Nln ions Walkley, and depressedratesof aerobicmicrobial action on the samples.
Samplesobtained from sealed or protected contexts, such as under stone paving, returned uninterpretable results due to the uncalculated effect of exposure to rainfall, temperature,and soil 0, Frink, The potential use of the OCR proceduregoesbeyond dating archaeologi- cal samples.
The formula used to calculate the OCR,, estimatedescribesa similar balancedsystem. The relationship betweeneach of the individual variables cannot be expressedin linear causeand effect terms.
OXIDIZABLE CARBON RATIO DATING 97 Other factors, asyet unidentified, affecting the oxidizability of the carbon- ized organic matter are subsumedwithin a. Radiocarbon and Oxidizable Carbon Ratio Dates from Modeling Regional Radiocarbon Trends: A Case Study from the East Texas Woodland Period . To date, there are a total of approximately radiocarbon dates. A Compendium of Radiocarbon and Oxidizable Carbon Ratio Dates from Frink, D. S. Application of the oxidizable carbon ratio dating.
Correlation between known Oxidizable Carbon Ratio age estimatesand known dates from earlier studies Frink, Rather, the effect of changesin one variable will be distributed throughout the equationby changesin one or more variables. The OCR formula reflects the variables of climate mean rainfall and temperature ,biota depth below surface,percentageof C, and pHparentmaterial soil texture and pHand time.
The factors of relief and aspect can be easily incorporatedinto the equation. The equation developed for the OCR procedure may apply to other pe- dogenic studies. The OCR equation describesa dynamic systemat the moment of analysis.
Effect of changesin any one or more variableswill be balanced,or distributed, throughout the system.
Oxidizable carbon ratio dating is not an objective independent dating method and does not provide evidence for long ages. ABSTRACT. Since its development as a dating tool, archaeologists have struggled with the interpretation of radiocarbon data due to its limitations in accuracy. Oxidizable carbon ratio dating is a method of dating in archaeology and earth science that can be used to derive or estimate the age of soil and sediment.
While the OCR-dating proceduresolvesthe equation for the variable time, the equationmay be solved for each of the vari- ables,provided that all of the other variablesare known. Locations of soil samplesanalyzedwith Oxidizable CarbonRatio procedurein this study. Noncultural soil samplesfrom Ohio are ana- lyzed to determinethe ageof specific soil horizons.
The sampleswere dried by the collectors before submissionto our laboratory. Four samples,discussedin detail below, were received in moist condition.
Soil texture is determinedby dry screening,with the mean texture calcu- lated by the percentageof weight of eachfraction according to USDA standard meshscreenssizes. Arbitrary valuesranging from 1 clay through 7 very coarse sand are assignedto each soil fraction, and the mean weight is calculated for each sample. As the object of analysisis charcoal, the resultsof the C analysesare not convertedto their equivalentorganic matter.
In computing the OCR formula, the mean annual rainfall is expressedin centimetersper year, and the mean annual temperatureis expressedin degreesFahrenheit.
The oxidizable carbon ratio (OCR), expressed as the ratio of total C by . corroborate the date estimates obtained through radiocarbon analyses, or, as is. newly developed absolute dating technique, the OCR carbon dating . In general, the ratio of total organic carbon to readily oxidisable organic carbon increases. A Compendium of Radiocarbon and Oxidizable Carbon Ratio Dates from with A Discussion of the Age and Dating of Select Components and.
The Fahrenheitscaleis employed to accommodatepergelic and cryic soils, where the mean annual temperature expressedin degreescentigradewould requirenegativenumbers,needlesslycom- plicating the computations. Although long-term fluctuations in mean annualtemperaturesand rainfall are commonthroughoutthe HolocenePeriod 10 yr agoto the present ,their deviationsfrom the modernmeanis slight.
The Oxidizable Carbon Ratio (OCR), expressed as the ratio of total C by loss- obtained by the OCR-dating procedure and 14C radiocarbon age estimates.
The late PleistocenePeriod,however, is characterizedby severaldramaticdeviationsfrom the modernmean Mayewski et al. For samplesobtained from late Pleistocenecontexts,however,the variablesof meanannualtemperatureand rainfall need to be adjusted. These adjustmentstake the form of an estimated averagetemperatureand rainfall based on local environmental reconstruction studies. Compari- sonsbetweenthe expectedand observedage estimatesfor these 16 cultural fea- tures demonstratea strong correlation Fig.
The four outlier samplesare from Connecticutand West Virginia. The two samplesfrom Connecticut were received in moist condition. Upon inquiry, it was discoveredthat the soils hadbeenstoredmoist on a shelteredporch for nearly 3 yr after excavation. Thesestorageconditions increasedthe effects of rainfall, temperature,and soil depth. Contextual and chemical data from 16 cultural featuresand 8 soil horizons. CL 27 Fort Bend Archeological Society 5.
Perttula, Timothy K. East Texas Archaeological Society Newsletter 8 6 Caddoan Archeology 7 4 Radiocarbon 39 3 : Saunders, Joe W. Mandel, Roger T. Saucier, E. Thurman Allen, C. Hallmark, Jay K. Johnson, Edwin H. Jackson, Charles M. Allen, Gary L. Stringer, Douglas S. Frink, James K.
Feathers, Stephen Williams, Kristen J. GremillionMalcolm F. Science Diachronic Research Foundation, Columbia, S. Tennis, Cynthia L. Waynne Cox, Jeffrey J. Durst, Donna D. Edmondson, Barbara A. Meissner, Steve A. Tomka, Douglas S. Frink, John G. Jones, and Rick C. Webb, Paul A.
Southern Indian Studies Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society The University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa. Worth, J. Early Georgia 24 1 : From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Archaeology of Eastern North America In Pedological Perspectives in Archaeological Research.
SSA Special Publication Accessed November 2, Killick, A. Fullen Pages Accessed December 27,